STOP the 34th Street Transitway
Home People's Stories: Enough is Enough! Contact Your Elected Officials Join Us and Take Action Fact Sheet Alternatives to BRT Calendar
About Us
News and Opinions
Elected Officials Write to DOT
Boondoggle on 34th Street
Taxpayers Shell Out $125 Million
Mayhem from 30th to 40th Streets
Transitway's Hidden Costs
"Above Ground Subway" = Blight
DOT Misleads The Public
Blocks Our Access
Transitway Tie-ups
Bad for Health, Too!
34th Street: Not a "Corridor"
Walker's Paradise
Arborcide
West Side Struggle
Story of One Mile
Urban Malls: Litany of Failure
Beware: Transitway Kills a Street
Transportation Planner:
Transitway Critic
Church Calls
Transitway “A Disaster”
Share Your Story…Comment
What You Can Do
Sign the Petition
The Murray Hill Neighborhood
Association

American Urban Malls: Failure After Failure

One of the Transitway's major features will be a pedestrian mall in the shopping area located between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, where only buses will be allowed on 34th Street. Yet similar malls across the country have failed. These include State Street in Chicago, Brattle Street in Cambridge, Washington Boulevard in Detroit and K Street in Sacramento. In these cases, cities have restored traffic to make the streets safer and more retail-friendly. On retail streets, people prefer a lively mix of shoppers and vehicles rather than big open spaces where they feel alone and vulnerable. And people mean more retail activity, higher commercial rents and increased revenues for cities.